20% Off Dirty Jigs and Nichols Lures, Through 01/21. Save Now

Buy 3 Get 1 FREE Hard Baits, Through 01/21. Save Now

Get a FREE BKK Hook Sample Pack. Learn More

FREE St. Croix Pro Lite Suit By Frogg Toggs with Purchase of St. Croix Rod. Shop Now

Markdowns on popular products - See all bargain offers

Omnia Fishing
  • Search Site
Omnia Fishing

Sugarloaf Lake

Published: Updated:

4 Fishing Reports
5 Followers

Sugarloaf Lake Fishing Reports

Filter by

All Species
All Seasons

Sort by

Reports from all past years within a 60-day time frame

  • Phelptwan

    Gold Ambassador

    9/24/22

    • Species

      Largemouth Bass

    • Season

      Fall

    • Technique

      Topwater Prop

    • Structure

      Open Water/Basin

    • Forage

      Bluegill

    • Water Temperature

      66°

    Water temp was 65-67. Bass were pushing all the schooling fry into the shallows and feeding pretty aggressively but the bite was pretty slow. We eventually developed a pretty steady top water bit on plopper/prop bait's. Managed to catch a few with the new Hellraizer as well.
  • Phelptwan

    Gold Ambassador

    9/22/21

    • Species

      Largemouth Bass

    • Season

      Spring (Pre-Spawn)

    • Technique

      Spinnerbaits

    • Structure

      Reeds

    • Forage

      Bluegill

    Early spring fishing is hit or miss on Sugarloaf. Jerkbaits and Spinnerbaits can produce decent numbers but quality doesn't really hit until Spawning season.
  • Phelptwan

    Gold Ambassador

    5/19/24

    • Species

      Largemouth Bass

    • Season

      Spring (Spawn)

    • Technique

      Frogs/Toads

    • Structure

      Lily Pads

    • Forage

      Bluegill

    • Water Temperature

      67°

    Water temp was 67 when we hit it, but about 71 when we got off the water. Little to no breeze as we fished. Very sunny and VERY clear water. Solid 6-7' visibility. Frogs were the winner of the day, caught several decent bass hitting the back pockets of pads as the bass swirled. Began throwing a BFS Popper (Damiki Umpa) at the popping bluegills and had a blast pulling in Bluegills as well as bass regularly. As the top water fizzled out, switched to a wacky rig and started targeting the grass lines and pulled in several more keepers.
  • Phelptwan

    Gold Ambassador

    9/10/22

    • Species

      Largemouth Bass

    • Season

      Fall

    • Technique

      Lipless Crankbaits

    • Structure

      Lily Pads

    • Forage

      Bluegill

    Water temp around 75, lots of fish busting on surface but couldn't get on a top water bite. Tried a ploppers, poppers, walking baits, and frogs, just didn't seem interested. Switched to some lipless cranks and started catching them right off the edges of the lily pads and drop offs. Pretty much cranking them in as fast as we could turn the handles. Did a bit of sight fishing in the shallows and caught them with a wacky worm, but the bait of the day was definitely the red eye.